Friday, 12 December 2014

FIX: Airport Utility does not find any devices - Mac OS X Yosemite (10.10.1)

Apple appears to have changed the way the Airport Utility admin application finds Airport and Time Capsule devices.  This may also apply to the Time Machine tools for backing up and restoring Mac files.  There is a simple fix...

Symptom: Under OS X Yosemite, the Apple Airport Utility (v6.3.4) fails to find any compatible Apple devices.  But "File / Configure Other" can be used successfully if you happen to know the IP address of the box you wish to administer.

So... The auto discovery mechanism must have got broken when Mac OS X 10.10 was released.

Fix: Switch off your Mac OS X firewall.  Reboot your Mac.  Try again!

Comment: This used to "just work" on earlier Mac OS X releases, but the new software smacks of poor design.  Surely the auto discovery protocol should play nicely with the stateful firewall on the local host.  If that's not possible for some reason, then the application needs to warn the user if their firewall settings must be changed for the application to work properly.

I find it particularly irksome that dropping the firewall isn't enough - you also have to reboot the Mac. Reminiscent of older Microsoft operating systems.

UPDATE: Another related bug in Yosemite (10.10.1).  In the Finder, can't connect to my Time Capsule share without dropping the firewall and rebooting.    That is, when I click on a short cut in Finder, the Finder hangs, then eventually announces that the Time Capsule can't be found.  But it just works if I switch off the Mac firewall and reboot the Mac.  This is crazy!  The Mac is acting as a client, not a server, so the firewall setting shouldn't matter.  Poor design or poor implementation?  I would be grateful for any insight into this mess.